Monday, June 14, 2010

Propellants: Black Powder - I

The invention of black powder (the first true "gunpowder") is credited to several sources, the Chinese, the Indians, the Arabs, the Germans and the English. Certainly, the original source seems to have been the Chinese by 900 AD or so, but they seem to have used it for medicinal and alchemical purposes initially, rather than use them for firearms. The Arabs mention a formula for gunpowder by the late 1200s. Gunpowder was used in firearms in India and Arabia by the early 1300s. Roger Bacon, an English monk, published a description of gunpowder back in 1242, although he did not claim to invent it. In 1268, he published a more exact formula, listing the proportions of the various ingredients to be used. Even though Roger Bacon was the first to describe an exact formula in the western world, curiously his notes (written in Latin) begin with what would be roughly translated in English as "As everyone knows, you can make ...". Black Berthold (or Berthold Schwartz), a medieval German monk, also conducted research on black powder in the early 1300s. It is possible that the secrets of black powder were brought back to Europe by the crusaders arriving back from the middle east. Black powder was used as a propellant from the 1300s all the way to the mid 1870s or so, and is still used by many avid black-powder hunters who wish to hunt using the same technologies that were available to their hallowed ancestors.

The primary three components of black powder are a fuel, an oxidizer and a stabilizer, mixed in various proportions. The fuel is usually charcoal or sugar, the oxidizer is usually potassium nitrate (KNO3) (or sometimes sodium nitrate, NaNO3) and the stabilizer is generally sulfur (S). The burning of the carbon (C) in the charcoal produces carbon dioxide and energy in the form of heat and light. Normally, the charcoal would burn at a normal rate when burnt in atmospheric air, but with an oxidizer that supplies extra oxygen, it burns much faster than usual. The final reaction produces nitrogen and carbon-dioxide gases and potassium sulfide. Gunpowder may be made using just potassium nitrate and charcoal, but the force is not as much as when sulfur is added. Sulfur also reduces the temperature at which the ignition takes place.

The proportions of the various ingredients of black powder have varied over time. Sir Francis Bacon's formula of 1268 called for 7 parts by weight of potassium nitrate, 5 parts of charcoal and 5 parts of sulfur, though some scholars maintain that he'd invented the modern ratio of 15:3:2 as well. By 1312, the records of the Battle of Crecy and the Battle of Agincourt show that the English had settled on a formula in the ratio 6:2:1 of KNO3, C and S, while the Germans were using 4:1:1 ratio. By the 1750s, the standard ratio for gunpowder used was 15:3:2 (i.e.) 75% potassium nitrate, 15% charcoal, 10% sulfur by weight and this ratio has stayed pretty much the same since. Other ratios were used for black powder not suitable for use for firearms (for instance, blasting powder used different ratios of the ame materials).

The charcoal used in the manufacture of black powder is generally manufactured from the wood of softwood trees. Softwood trees are preferred because the charcoal from hardwood trees leave too much ash behind after combustion. According to W.W. Greener's, The Gun and Its Development, Second Edition, trees such as willow, black dogwood, alder etc are/were traditionally used in England to manufacture charcoal. In India, the woods of the locally available Grambush plant (Cythus Cajan), Parkinsonia and Milk Edge (Euphorbia Tiraculli) are used. In America, cottonwood, soft pine, redwood and western cedar are the trees of choice. The trees are generally felled in springtime, because the bark is easier to remove from the tree trunks during this time, though winter wood may also be used. The removal of bark is a necessity because it prevents the scintillation of gunpowder. The wood is cut into chips or smaller pieces about 1-4 inches in diameter and put into a vessel with a tight fitting lid. There is a small hole on top of the vessel to allow the escape of other gases. The vessel is then placed on a hot fire and heated, until organic gases begin to escape from the wood through the small hole. The gas is called wood-gas and is primarily composed of methane. This gas may be ignited with a match as it is escaping through the hole. When the gas stops issuing out of the hole, the flame goes out and this indicates that the wood has been converted to charcoal. The time taken for charring depends on the thickness of the wood pieces, as well as the heat of the furnace. Charcoal made at 240 degrees centigrade will readily ignite at 330 degrees centigrade, whereas charcoal made at 950 degrees centigrade will take nearly 1900 degrees to ignite. Hence, the best charcoal for gunpowder is made at lower temperatures. The vessel is allowed to cool and then the charcoal is removed and ground up into a powder. For uniform results, the vessels used to make charcoal are all kept at the same temperature. After the powder is ground up, it is allowed to sit for a couple of weeks. The reason for this is that freshly ground-up charcoal is highly prone to spontaneous combustion, but if it is allowed to sit for 10-12 days, it loses this property and can now be used to make gunpowder more safely.

The second ingredient of black powder is Potassium Nitrate (KNO3), commonly known as saltpeter. This occurs naturally as an efflorescence on the ground in some parts of the world, such as India and Arabia and the Andalusia region of Spain, due to the weather conditions. In parts of Europe, it was manufactured by preparing beds of manure mixed with wood ashes and leaching with urine for a period of time. In France and Sweden, the mortar from old farm walls and stables were a source for saltpeter Another source was bat dung from caves. Sodium nitrate was also used as an alternative for a while, as it was available in the Chilean desert. In the 1600s, most of Europe was importing saltpeter from ports in the Gujarat region of India. By the late 1700s and early 1800s, England's source of potassium nitrate was entirely from the Gangetic plains of India, especially from the Bengal and Oudh regions where it was naturally occurring. The salt was collected here off the ground, mixed with water and boiled and the solution then placed in shallow troughs and allowed to evaporate in the sun, leaving behind impure saltpeter crystals (called "grough saltpeter"). These were then packed into gunny bags and shipped off to England for refining. On arrival at the Royal Waltham mills in England, about two tons of the grough saltpeter were put in a large vat and dissolved in 275 gallons of water. The mixture was heated for about two hours to allow the contents to boil, the specific gravity being 1.49 and the temperature of water getting close to 230 F. Scum rising to the surface was skimmed off until no more scum was generated. Then more cold water was added and the solution was heated and then allowed to cool to 220 F. The solution was then pumped into shallow trays and allowed to cool. The cooling would crystallize the excess potassium nitrate, while the solution would contain the impurities of sulphates, chlorides etc. The solution was gently agitated to prevent formation of large crystals and form a flour instead. The flour was then washed three times and a small sample was tested to make sure it was pure enough, before the batch was used.

These days, most potassium nitrate is generally mass-produced using the Haber process, which was invented by Fritz Haber shortly before WW-I. This consists of combining nitrogen with hydrogen in the presence of a catalyst, to produce ammonia (NH3). This ammonia is then oxidized to produce nitrates. The advantage of this process is that the raw ingredients are all abundantly available in nature (nitrogen and oxygen from the air and hydrogen and oxygen from water) and thus cannot be embargoed. During WW-I, the allies had access to large naturally occurring deposits of nitrates from Chile, but the Germans were cut off from this supply and had to produce their own. It was strongly suggested that without Haber's process, the Germans could not have gone to war or would have had to surrender much earlier. Haber received a Nobel prize for his discovery. Ironically, he was forced to leave Germany by the Nazis in the 1930s simply because he was Jewish.

Sulfur is also obtained naturally around the world, mostly around hot springs and volcanic regions. It is found naturally in Sicily, Japan, Chile, Indonesia etc. It was known in ancient China and India as well, where it was extracted from pyrite ores. In fact, the word "Sulfur" is actually of Sanskrit origin (sulvari). It is also found around petroleum deposits. Sulfur is generally refined by using distillation or sublimation. Historically, the two methods used for purifying sulfur were the Sicilian process (from ancient times) and the Frasch process (used from 1890s onward till about 2002). The Claus process extracts sulfur from hydrogen sulfide gas and is the process of choice in modern times.

In the next post, we will discuss how these ingredients are combined to make black powder.

Propellants: Basics

After our study of barrel making technologies, we will devote some time in the study of propellants. A propellant is the substance that when burned, generates pressurized gas to push the bullet out of the barrel of the gun and onto its target. For most of firearms history, black powder was the main propellant of choice until about the late 1800s or so when it began to be replaced by smokeless powders and cordite.

The main requirements of propellants are:
  • Stability: The propellant should not easily ignite if it is shaken or accidentally dropped.
  • Long shelf life
  • Less residue: Burning black powder leaves a lot of residue behind in the barrel, which means that the user has to spend time cleaning the barrel often. Newer powders leave very little residue behind.
  • Uniformity: The propellant should be manufactured so that it provides a similar amount of propulsive force, even if one batch of propellant is manufactured at a different time from another batch, or by another manufacturer. This way, the firearm's range and accuracy are not compromised when firing cartridges manufactured at different times and places.
  • Low explosive power: This one is a bit hard for newbies to understand. Basically, the propellant should burn pretty violently when lit, but not quickly enough for the speed of the flame front to exceed the speed of sound (otherwise, it is classified as a "high explosive".) The idea is that the burning propellant generates pressurized gas, which expands out and pushes the bullet out at speed. The expansive forces are also acting on the inside of the barrel (which is made of iron or steel), which has a certain elasticity. The forces acting on the barrel shouldn't apply force at a rate greater than what the barrel's elasticity can handle, otherwise the barrel will explode. Therefore, a good propellant should be explosive enough so that the maximum speed of the bullet can be achieved, but not explosive enough to convert the firearm into a hand-grenade! This is why people don't use TNT or RDX in modern propellants! In some cases, people use high-explosives (e.g. nitroglycerine) for propellants, but they add enough stabilizers to slow down the burn time of the high-explosive so that it can be safely used as a propellant.
In the next few posts, we will study the history of propellants and their manufacturing techniques.

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Barrel Making: Making a Modern Steel Barrel - Part II

In our previous post, we saw how what kinds of steel are chosen to make barrels and the process by which they are drilled. Now we will continue discussing the process, after the barrel has been drilled.

As we noted in our previous post, a deep hole drill bit is designed to drill a hole slightly smaller than the desired bore. For instance, if the final gun barrel is supposed to have a bore of 5.56 mm., the drill bit might drill a hole about 5.35 - 5.40 mm. in diameter. So the next operation to be done is called reaming and the process uses a reaming machine to do this.

Reaming


The picture above is a reaming tool. A reaming tool is made of either tool steel or (in more modern times) tungsten carbide. A typical reaming bit is a cylindrical tool which has a set of multiple straight or helical cutting edges which are parallel to each other on the circumference of the cylinder. A reaming tool only removes a small amount of material (typically between 0.1 and 0.2 mm. at most) and is used to perform accurate sizing of a bore's diameter and also produce a smooth finish on the inside of the barrel. The white part in the picture above is just soft tape and is present to prevent the reamer from vibrating when it is inside the barrel.



The reamer bit is put in through the barrel and then oil is pumped in, but at a lower pressure than the drilling operation we saw in the previous post. Unlike drilling, in the reaming operation, the reaming tool is rotated and the barrel is kept still. The reaming tool is rotated at speeds of 200 - 500 rpm or so and the barrel is pulled through the reaming tool at a rate of about 2 - 5 cm. per minute or so. The oil keeps the reaming tool cool and flushes out any metal filings. In the picture above, you can see the reaming tool coming out of the barrel and dirty oil coming out of the barrel as well. The oil is filtered by a series of sieves to remove the metal particles and the oil is recycled.

Reaming produces a much more smoother finish than drilling and only removes a small part of the material, hence this is a finishing up operation. Some low quality barrel manufacturers skip the reaming operation altogether and merely drill the hole to the desired bore, which saves a bit of money, but doesn't provide a dimensionally accurate hole. All quality barrel manufacturers invariably drill a hole a little smaller than the desired bore and then use a reamer to make it the exact diameter and finish the insides with a smooth finish.

Rifling

The next process after reaming is done is to add rifling to the barrel. We've already studied the various methods of rifling previously (i.e.)
We will not talk much about the rifling techniques here, since they've already been discussed. Cut rifling is generally preferred by small custom barrel makers and the last four methods are used by larger gun making companies. Note that broach rifling, button rifling, hammer forging and flow forming add additional stress to the barrel due to their methods of machining.

Stress Relieving

Because of the drilling, reaming and rifling operations, considerable stress is induced into the barrel and this needs to be stress relieved again before further operations can happen. If you remember, we mentioned that the barrel blanks are already stress-relieved by the external vendor before they're delivered to the barrel maker. This operation needs to happen again after the rifling operation is done, because the above three operations introduce considerable stress on the barrel and may cause it to deform in the next few operations if this isn't done.

There are usually two ways of stress relieving a barrel. The first way (traditional method) is to heat the barrel to about 525 - 550 degrees centigrade and then let it cool slowly back to room temperature. The second method (cryogenic stress relieving) is to cool the barrel to extremely low temperatures (say -185 degrees centigrade) and control the cooling time and temperature cycle. At this temperature, the molecules that were pushed out of the way during the machining operations are realigned again and this relieves the stress on the barrel.

Profiling or Contouring

After the rifling operation is done, the barrel may be profiled or contoured on the outside. Basically, when a gun is fired, the most pressure occurs on the breech end of the weapon (i.e.) the side where the cartridge is, and the least pressure is at the other end of the barrel (i.e.) the muzzle. Hence, it is not necessary for the barrel to be of uniform thickness throughout the length of the barrel. Several manufacturers reduce the weight of the gun by removing material from the outside of the barrel, so that the walls of the muzzle end are thinner than the walls on the breech end. This operation is called contouring or profiling.


These days, most contouring operations are done using a Computerized Numerically Controlled (CNC) lathe. The precise profile of the outside of the barrel is fed into a computer, which controls the lathe and produces the desired profile on the barrel.

Note that if proper stress relieving was not done earlier, the act of contouring may distort the barrel. This is because the stored stress from the earlier processes will start to act upon the side of the barrel where the outside is thinner and the bore will become bell-shaped.

Lapping

The final process done to the steel barrel is called lapping. Generally, lapping is only done to really high-end custom made barrels and is not normally done on mass-produced barrels. The reasons to perform lapping are to remove any machining marks, surface polish the inside of the barrel, eliminate any tight spots etc. This operation is generally a manual one and is done by an expert. 


Initially a rod similar to a cleaning rod is pushed into the barrel. Then the barrel is placed vertically and molten lead is poured down the other end of the barrel and allowed to solidify. When the lead has solidified, it is shaped exactly like the shape of the inside of the barrel. The lead lap is then extracted and lapping paste is added to the outside. Lapping paste is similar to the paste that is used to grind valves in automobile engines. The rod is then pulled and pushed through the length of the barrel multiple times and more paste or oil are added as needed. This process polishes the inside of the barrel to a very fine surface.

After this process, the barrel may be mounted to a stock, sights may be attached on the exterior, it may be chambered for a given cartridge and the barrel itself may be blued or browned along with the action of the gun.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Barrel Making: Making a Modern Steel Barrel - Part I

We've seen in our previous post that with the rise of smokeless powders replacing the old black gunpowder, steel barrels became more popular as these could withstand the higher pressures generated by smokeless powders. We will now study some of the processes involved in making a modern steel barrel.

Materials Used

Steel is used obviously, otherwise we wouldn't be discussing it in this chapter :). The steel used has to be able to withstand high pressures of over 50,000 psi (340,000 kpa) and special steels are needed to do this. There are two types of steel generally used in modern barrels:

The first type is an Chrome-Molybdenum steel alloy (called chrome-moly for short). This is the same steel alloy that is used to make truck axles, connecting rods and propeller shafts. In the US, such steels are designated by grades such as AISI 4140, AISI 4150, AISI 4340 and so on. The British equivalent of these steels is EN 19, EN 24 etc. These steels are generally used for military grade firearms as well as hunting rifles.

The other type is a stainless steel alloy such as 416 type stainless steel. This is not a true fully austenitic stainless steel such as the types used in making cutlery items like knives and forks. The 416 type stainless steel is a martensitic steel which can be hardened by heat treating, similar to carbon steel. It is more accurately a high chrome content (> 10%) steel having enough sulphur to give it good machining properties. This steel is generally used by target shooters and is considered to be easier to machine accurately than chrome-moly steels. It is also more expensive than chrome-moly steel, has lesser life and is more difficult to black. Hence, military and hunting rifles use chrome-moly steel while target shooters prefer stainless steel.

Whatever the type of steel chosen, the most important characteristics of the steel are ease of machining, longevity and strength. Secondary considerations are resistance to corrosion and ability to be blued.

It is important for these steels to have high tensile strength (i.e.) resistance to being pulled apart. These steels can easily withstand over 100,000 psi which is quite a bit over the maximum expected pressure. Hardening steels generally increases tensile strength, but it tends to make them brittle and susceptible to hard knocks, hence these steels must withstand shock as well. A tradeoff is made between tensile strength and impact strength and therefore, the barrels are hardened to between 25 and 32 on the Rockwell C hardness scale.

The steel for the barrels is generally not made by the barrel makers themselves, but instead arrives from external vendors in lengths of 5 - 7.5 meter (16.5 - 24.5 feet) long cylindrical bars and diameter depending on the barrel makers specifications. For instance, barrels intended for hunting rifles have a diameter of 3.25 cm. (1.4 inches) and barrels for smaller .22 rifles may be 2.5 cm. (1 inch) in diameter. The external vendor generally stress-relieves the steel bars before delivery. This is done by heating the bars to 525 - 550 degrees centigrade (977 - 1022 degrees fahrenheit) and then allowing the bars to cool slowly. If the bars are not stress-relieved before hand, they may split during the machining process.

The first step of the process is to cut the bars to the required length of gun barrels (e.g. 16 inches, 18 inches, 20 inches, or for metric speakers, 450 mm. or 500 mm. or whatever) and the ends are squared off. Then a hole must be drilled into the barrel.

Drilling Techniques
Everyone knows how to drill a hole into a wooden plank or wall, using a small hand-drill or power drill. Some may have seen or handled a drill press in a machine shop and used it to drill into a mild steel plate. Drilling a hole into a gun (especially rifle barrels) is a completely different proposition than drilling a hole into a wooden plank or a mild-steel plate. For one, a rifle barrel is a lot longer and the drill needs to penetrate deep into the barrel. The second problem is accuracy. For a gun barrel, it is critical that the drill does not deviate much from the center of the barrel, and this has to be true for the entire length of the barrel, which may be 40-50 cm. long or more. This means the ratio of diameter to length of the hole is unusually high for gun barrels. For example, an M-16 rifle barrel has a diameter of 5.56 mm. and a length of 508 mm. (20 inches), which means the ratio of length to diameter of this barrel is approximately 91:1.

The way to drill into a barrel is to use a special deep hole drill (also called a gun drill) and a special drill bit. First, we take a look at the drill bit used:


The drill bit is made of tool steel or tungsten carbide (these days, tungsten carbide is more common). The diameter of the drill bit is slightly smaller than the required diameter of the barrel. For instance, if the barrel bore is 5.56 mm, the drill bit is designed drill a hole slightly smaller than this (say 5.35 - 5.40 mm.) Note that the drill bit is asymmetric (V-shaped) and only has a cutting edge on one side. The drill bit is also ground so that the forces acting on the cutting edge will keep the drill bit centered in the work piece automatically. The drill bit is also hollow, as can be seen by the two holes at the end of the drill bit. The drill bit is mounted to a steel tube and then oil is pumped under pressure through the drill bit holes. As the drill bit makes its way through the barrel, the oil serves to keep the drill bit cool. Also, the metal shavings are carried out of the barrel by the oil via the V-channel in the middle of the bit. The oil is then passed through a series of sieves to filter out the metal shavings and the oil is recycled into the main tank.

In some other drill bits, there is a single hole in the middle. Oil is pumped through the V part and the oil and metal shavings exit through the hole in the drill bit.

Now we look at the deep hole drilling machine that uses such a drill bit.

In this machine, you can see a pressure gauge B at the bottom end of the photo. The oil is pumped through the pipe A into the drill bit. The barrel blank to be drilled is mounted to the chuck D on the top part of the photo. The drill passes through a couple of guide bushes (C) before entering the barrel. The guides may be seen in the middle of the photo.

The barrel is usually initially pre-drilled to a few mm. depth before being mounted to this machine, to give the drill bit an initial starting hole.

In most deep drilling machines, the drill bit is held steady and the barrel is rotated around it at speeds of 2000 - 5000 rpm. In some newer machines, the barrel is held steady and the drill bit is rotated. In some cases, both are rotated. However, the technique of holding the drill bit steady and rotating the barrel is preferred because this method keeps the drill bit self-centered.

Oil is pumped at high pressure from the end A seen at the bottom of the picture. You can see the dirty oil carrying metal shavings coming out of the channel E near one of the supporting guide bushes in the middle-right of the picture. This oil is passed through a series of filters to extract all the metal shavings and the oil is then recycled back into the main tank.

The drill bit is fed into the barrel at a slow rate of approximately one inch (2.5 cm.) per minute, so a 20-inch M-16 rifle barrel will take approximately 20 minutes to drill completely. The drill bit is initially held in the straight position by the guide bushes and prevented from moving side to side, but as it penetrates deeper into the barrel, the sides of the hole itself prevent the bit from moving around too much. Variations in the consistency of the barrel material can also cause the drill bit to wander a little. The barrel must also be straightened (or trued) before being mounted on the deep drill, because the barrel is rotated at high speed during the drilling process and any imbalance in the shape of the barrel will be magnified when it is spinning at such high speeds.

As we noted earlier, the drill bit is designed to cut a hole slightly smaller than the final diameter of the barrel. So if the desired final diameter is 5.56 mm., this process drills a hole that is 5.35 - 5.40 mm in diameter. The next process that we will study is used to enlarge the barrel to its final diameter.

Sunday, June 6, 2010

Barrel Making: The Rise of Steel Barrels

In the previous few posts, we've seen a lot of detail about the so-called damascus barrels. We've also seen a genuine damascus barrel is very beautiful and requires a lot of labor to produce and is therefore expensive. In our last post, we also saw how fake damascus barrels were produced. The number of cheap fakes that were produced served to lower the public's perception of damascus barrels in general, because the fake barrels burst a lot easier and wore out quickly.

Meanwhile, various steel-making processes were improving and some of the prominent steels in the late 1800s were the Whitworth Fluid Compressed Steel, the Siemens-Martin process steel and Krupp Steel.

Whitworth fluid compressed steel was invented by Mr. Joseph Whitworth, who we already talked about when discussing polygonal bore rifling and the Whitworth rifle. Mr. Whitworth was the eminent mechanical engineer of his day and came up with a way of producing a stronger cast steel. His process consists of melting a steel ingot into a mold and applying pressure of up to 6 tons/sq. inch to the mold while the steel is in a liquid state. The pressure drives out all the gases and eliminates blowholes in the cast steel. It also increases the density and strength of the steel. According to W.W. Greener's book, The Gun and its Development, with the introduction of choke boring in shotgun barrels, whitworth steel was found very suitable for this process and started replacing damascus barrels, and he mentions in 1875, "Whitworth steel was giving great satisfaction for rifle barrels, a leading London gun-maker adopted it for shotgun barrels." The leading London gun-maker was Purdey & Sons, who used Whitworth steel exclusively for years after that. Use of Whitworth steel for gun-making spread to America as well and well known makers such as Parker, L.C. Smith and Lefevre were making guns using this steel, way into the 1930s.

In the Siemens Martin process, pig iron is melted in a reverberatory furnace and wrought iron or iron ores are added until a desired degree of carbonization is reached. Oxides are removed and manganese and carbon are added by using a small quantity of ferromanganese. The amount of carbon left is ascertained by dipping a small ladle into the melted metal and cooling it and then breaking it apart and analyzing it. If found to be the right amount, the rest of the metal is poured into ingots and allowed to cool. Then the ingots are passed between rollers to reduce the thickness to the desired size. This process is slower than the Bessemer process, but it allows the manufacturer to more precisely produce the desired grade of steel of a uniform quality.

Another big manufacturer of barrels using the fluid-steel process was Krupp of Essen, Germany. Krupp's process used a slightly different composition of steel and was also used by several gun makers.

In 1888, the Guardians of the Birmingham Proof House (a British Government organization whose responsibility was to test all gun barrels made in the Birmingham area) ran a test on the strength of several gun barrels. The board appointed a committee composed of representatives of various prominent manufacturers of the area and ran the same tests against a series of barrels of five types:
  1. English damascus twist barrels, hand forged (3 specimens)
  2. English damascus twist barrels, machine forged (17 specimens)
  3. Foreign damascus twist barrels (6 specimens)
  4. English steel barrels (11 specimens)
  5. Foreign steel barrels (2 specimens)
In all, thirty nine specimens of barrels were tested, with a total of 117 different barrels used for testing. The barrels were initially loaded with a standard Proof House test amount of gunpowder and shot, using the same machinery to load, to ensure that the amount of tamping down of gunpowder and shot was uniform. Then all barrels were fired and then checked for signs of bulging and those with bulges were rejected. The next test used a heavier gunpowder charge and heavier shot and the remaining barrels were fired again and tested for bulges and the tests were repeated using more and more gunpowder and shot.

The following screenshot shows the results of the top 20 barrels (image courtesy of G.T. Teasdale-Buckell's Experts on Guns and Shooting, page 540):



We have already discussed damascus barrel grades such as the "laminated steel" and "best damascus steel" in this post previously. The best barrel was a laminated steel (a type of damascus steel) barrel, followed by a Whitworth fluid steel barrel, followed by another damascus steel ("Best damascus" grade) and a Siemens-Martin steel barrel. Note how English barrels dominate the test because some of the foreign types (especially Belgian barrels) used weaker iron in their manufacture. While Whitworth steel finished second in this test, they were just getting started in perfecting the technology and it soon became a lot cheaper and faster to manufacture as well. By 1895, when they held another test, Whitworth steel came first in this test.

The rise of smokeless powders also had a lot to do with the decline of damascus barrels. Smokeless powders generate a lot more force than black powders. Smokeless powders also burn along the length of the barrel since they're slower burning than black powders, which mainly burn at the breech end and blow out an unburnt quantity out of the muzzle. Many damascus barrels couldn't withstand such pressures and those that could needed a lot more time and effort to manufacture. Hence steel barrels became more and more popular as smokeless powder became prevalent.

The next post will deal with manufacturing of modern steel barrels.

Barrel Making: Fake Damascus Barrels

In our previous three posts, we saw beautiful examples of damascus barrels and studied the method of manufacture of these barrels. Due to the labor intensive nature of manufacture of these barrels, these were reserved for use with fine shotguns and revolvers. Thus, the presence of a damascus barrel on a gun was the sign of a high-quality and expensive product. However, some unscrupulous manufacturers soon found some ways to make inferior copies of these products, which they could then sell at a higher price as quality weapons.

One of the ways to do this was to take a barrel made of very cheap iron and then wind a very thin layer of superior damascus steel on the outside. An illustration of this process is shown below:


In the above, an inner tube is made of cheap iron. You can see the fibers of this cheaper iron tube, which run horizontally along the tube. Around this is wound a thin strip of damascus steel. You can see how the fibers of the damascus steel run along the length of the spiral. When the two are welded together, this has the appearance of a genuine damascus barrel and can only be told apart when pickling in acid, as the cheaper iron on the inside gets eaten away much faster than the surface layer. This practise was heavily used by some counterfeit manufacturers in Liege, Belgium.

Another way to imitate stub damascus is to use a cheaper iron. Real stub damascus steel is made using iron from old horse-shoe nails, which are melted along with steel from broken files and coach springs in a puddling furnace, which makes the blooms used to make the rods used for damascus steel. The cheaper technique was to use scrap cuttings of iron and put them in a charcoal furnace (instead of a puddling furnace) and then stain them in a particular way to resemble the watering pattern of damascus steel. The counterfeiters would stain the barrels very dark and then, a weak solution of muriatic acid would be applied with a sponge to those areas where the staining was darker, to make it more even. Then they would scald the barrel in hot water to stop the staining process. The result was very hard to tell apart from the real thing, except by subjecting the barrel to stress testing. This technique was common in England, as well as parts of Europe.

Similarly, barrels made of "threepenny skelp", "twopenny skelp" or "sham damn skelp" were made of very inferior materials and sold as damascus steel barrels. In most skelp barrels, the rods were not twisted together before manufacturing and hence the grain of the iron would be different from that of a damascus barrel. The solution to this was to paint on a cheap stain that resembled a fine English twist barrel, or put cheap engraving on the outside to resemble a damascus twist. One way to find out fakes was to remove the barrel from its wooden stock, because the forgers usually didn't bother to touch those parts which are hidden by the wood.


As you can see in the above, this fake damascus barrel gun hasn't aged very well due to its inferior materials. It is made of cheap iron and has an engraved twisted pattern on it to try and imitate the patterns of a low-end or single twist damascus barrel.



In our next example above, the barrels are also made of cheap iron, but the attempt is to fake the patterns of a three-stripe damascus or fine English damascus steel barrel. In this case, the pattern is applied by using a heavy roller on the outside surface of the barrel to engrave the pattern.




In the above two examples, the forger copied the pattern off a real damascus barrel and transferred it to the barrels using a painting technique called decalcomania, which was invented originally to copy designs onto pottery. The process of decalcomania is still with us today, we only call it by its shorter name, "decal."

In all these pictures, the reader might be struck by how badly worn out these imitations are, compared to the genuine damascus steel barrels of the previous few threads. This is because of the inferior quality and workmanship of the materials. Unfortunately when these were brand new, some of these were hard to tell apart from the real thing.

Barrel Making: Pattern Welded or Damascus Barrels - III

In the previous two posts, we looked into the history and development of damascus barrels throughout the world. Now we will look at some samples of such weapons. Before reading this post, it might be worthwhile to read through the previous post to understand how these barrels were manufactured.

Single Iron or Single Stripe Damascus


The first example we see above is a double barreled gun made of what is called "single iron stub damascus" which was used for the cheapest damascus barrels. In this type, a single twisted rod is flattened into a ribbon which is twisted around in a spiral form into one barrel. Two separate single barrels were made this way and welded together to make a double barreled gun. As you can see, the pattern has swirly lines, but is not as regular as some of the following examples. The raw materials used to make this rod came from old horse-shoe nails, broken files and coach springs.


Two Iron or Two Stripe Damascus


In the above example, we see a double barreled shotgun made with what is called a "two-iron damascus" type. In this type, two twisted rods, each one twisting in a different direction, are taken and rolled into a single ribbon, which is then wound in a spiral form into a single barrel. Two such single barrels were made and then welded together at the center to form the double barreled gun. Notice the rich patterning of each barrel in the above picture and compare it with the single-iron damascus type.

Three Iron Damascus or English Damascus



The above double barreled weapon is a three-iron damascus, otherwise known as an English damascus. This one uses three twisted rods which are combined into a single ribbon, which is then wound in a spiral form to make a barrel. Note the fineness and richness in patterning compared to the ones above. This type was used for the finest English sporting guns.

Laminated Steel and Silver Steel Damascus



In the above two images, we see fine examples of laminated steel damascus and silver-steel damascus. As with the three-iron damascus, these are made with three twisted rods, but the difference is the composition of the materials used to make the rods. These two use a higher percentage of steel and a better quality of iron to make the rods. Also, in laminated steel damascus, the iron and steel plates are piled in a different order before being combined, which gives the patterns a different shape than the other examples.

Six Stripe Damascus


As mentioned in our previous post, the English did not often make ribbons using more than three twisted rods, as they determined that the pattern was fine enough and that the pattern was not significantly improved by using more twisted rods. The Belgians on the other hand, used to manufacture some barrels using six twisted rods, each of which was twisted much more than the English manufacturers (They would use 18 turns per inch, whereas no English manufacturer would exceed 8 turns per inch, when twisting the rods). This gave it a beautiful finish, but it wasn't as strong as English barrels, because the excessive twisting actually weakened the barrels a bit. An example of a six-stripe Belgian made barrel is above.